4/10 Fair
The antiquated motel needs some upgrade.
James
James, 1-night trip
Three Judges Motel
Mountain hotel in New Haven
At Three Judges Motel, you'll be within a 10-minute drive of Yale University and Yale-New Haven Hospital. Guests will have free perks like WiFi and self parking.
Popular amenities
- Free parking
- Free WiFi
- Air conditioning
- 24/7 front desk
Main amenities (2)
- Housekeeping once per stay
- 24-hour front desk
Feel at home (4)
- Private bathroom
- In-room climate control (air conditioning)
- Limited housekeeping
- Free self parking
$80 nightly
$92 total
Feb 26 - Feb 27
Total with taxes and fees
Room options
Check availability for these dates
Deluxe Single Room
Highlights
Air conditioning
Mini-fridge
Separate bedroom
Shower/tub combination
Private bathroom
Laptop workspace
Desk
- 300 sq ft
- 1 bedroom
- Sleeps 2
- 1 King Bed
Comfort Double or Twin Room
Highlights
Air conditioning
Separate bedroom
Shower/tub combination
Private bathroom
Laptop workspace
Desk
- 300 sq ft
- 1 bedroom
- Sleeps 2
- 1 Double Bed
Similar properties
Best Western Executive Hotel Of New Haven - West Haven
- Pool
- Free parking
- Free WiFi
- Connecting rooms available
Very Good
1,564 reviews
$91 nightly
$105 total
Feb 26 - Feb 27
Total with taxes and fees
Motel 6 New Haven - Branford, CT
- Pet friendly
- Free parking
- Free WiFi
- Restaurant
Good
1,012 reviews
$67 nightly
$77 total
Mar 2 - Mar 3
Total with taxes and fees
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham New Haven
- Free breakfast
- Pet friendly
- Parking available
- Free WiFi
1,233 reviews
$105 nightly
$121 total
Mar 5 - Mar 6
Total with taxes and fees
New Haven Hotel
- Pet friendly
- Parking available
- Free WiFi
- Connecting rooms available
Wonderful
2,036 reviews
$101 nightly
$116 total
Mar 22 - Mar 23
Total with taxes and fees
The Best Way Inn
- Free parking
- Free WiFi
- Air conditioning
- 24/7 front desk
38 reviews
$65 nightly
$75 total
Mar 27 - Mar 28
Total with taxes and fees
Hamden Hotel and Suites – Hamden New Haven
- Free breakfast
- Pet friendly
- Free parking
- Free WiFi
1,001 reviews
$99 nightly
$114 total
Feb 26 - Feb 27
Total with taxes and fees
Heritage Hotel, Golf & Conference Center
- Pool
- Spa
- Pet friendly
- Free parking
Very Good
1,014 reviews
$118 nightly
$135 total
Feb 26 - Feb 27
Total with taxes and fees
Cambria Hotel New Haven University Area
- Pet friendly
- Parking available
- Free WiFi
- Restaurant
Excellent
1,020 reviews
$106 nightly
$121 total
Mar 22 - Mar 23
Total with taxes and fees
Hampton Inn & Suites New Haven - South - West Haven
- Pool
- Free breakfast
- Pet friendly
- Parking available
Very Good
1,000 reviews
$114 nightly
$131 total
Mar 1 - Mar 2
Total with taxes and fees
Motel 6 Milford, CT
- Pet friendly
- Free parking
- Free WiFi
- Air conditioning
1,005 reviews
$55 nightly
$64 total
Mar 18 - Mar 19
Total with taxes and fees
Earn OneKeyCash on thousands of hotels when you sign in and book. More rewards for more adventures!
About the neighborhood
1560 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT, 06515
About this property
Three Judges Motel
At Three Judges Motel, you'll be within a 10-minute drive of Yale University and Yale-New Haven Hospital. Guests will have free perks like WiFi and self parking.
At a glance
Property amenities
Room amenities
Frequently asked questions
Have a question?
Get instant answers with AI powered search of property information and reviews.
Three Judges Motel Reviews
4.2
Cleanliness
3.4
Amenities
5.6
Staff & service
3.8
Property conditions & facilities
8/10 Very good
In the hood. Like hood hood. But staff got you if you ask for a room in the back away from the base heads. Front desk dudes are chill. Dont bring your girl.
Luke
Luke, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
This overnight was terrible for us, never again
Pavel
Pavel, 1-night trip
4/10 Fair
bugs and hairs inside of the bed. dried urine trace on toilet. dust everhwhere. They just need to pay 20 min more attention on what they are doing i hope it will fix their problem
yavuz caner
yavuz caner, 1-night trip
10/10 Exceptional
Good
Sean
Sean, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Toilet had piss all over it man! The shower curtains were molded
Jamarco
Jamarco, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Changed room 3 times
Yashira
Yashira, 2-night trip
2/10 Poor
Disappointed
The towel was nasty the beds had stane on it the bathroom tub was nasty
Taramattie
Taramattie, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Staff was horrible and kicked us to street in bittercold weather after purse was stolen. And wouldnt wait to comfirm booking.. had to rebook doubble price and get screamed att as we walkwd back into hotel w new reservation had ploice threats untill staff who couldnr speak english finnaly understood us and saw we paid twicw finnal shoewd us to room
casey
casey, 1-night trip
6/10 Good
Bad area
Curtis
Curtis, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Do not I repeat do not come here for a stay. Crack heads all over the place. The room is just horrific sheets and things didn’t look clean. Only a few channels on the tv. Never again.
Quran
Quran, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
When I checked in, I noticed it looked kind of sketchy. And about midnight I heard people walking around the parking lot. It was a bunch of homeless people looking in and underneath cars. I informed the front desk and he said they’re harmless. There was no way I could stay there so I left within 30 minutes of arrival
Glen
Glen, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Don’t do it
Would not recommend
Curtis
Curtis, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Trap hotel
Upon reaching i was told they did not accept reservations after i made one..on top of that its a trap hotel..drug addicts and prostitutes has taven over this place..now the room was dirty especially the bathroom..the amount of dirt that covered the tub..couldn't even shower..toilet was nasty...i recommend not staying there if you want comfortability and cleanliness also without a place full of addicts and prostitute s.
Donruletta
Donruletta, 1-night trip
4/10 Fair
It had no stairs and I asked for a 1st floor room ,it was dirty
Lee
Lee, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
The room reeked of cigarettes, the window didn’t open for ventilation, and turning on the AC only made the smell worse. The smoke detector was taken out of the ceiling. Every surface was grimy and stained. There was no hot water. When checking for bed bugs, I found a half-eaten moldy cookie under the bed with bugs on it. There was a large group of sketchy people hanging around the gas station next door and occasionally running through the motel property. I checked out after an hour. The pictures Expedia shows are far from reality. The staff member at the front desk seemed nice, but that is the only positive thing I have to say about the experience.
Hayden
Hayden, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
The hotel room looked like it was not completed from a remodel or renovation, lacking grout. It had chips and uneven paint. The floor looked disgusting. The heating AC unit was extremely loud. There are only overhead lights, no bedside table lamps. No UBS connections. Wi-Fi is available, but you have to ask for the password – it is not provided. The area does not feel safe. A lot of activity in the parking lot would confirm that at 3, 4 and 5 AM. There are no amenities, provided other than a tiny wrapped soap. The towels were stained, rough and small. This Desk attendant tried very hard to be helpful, assisting with a room change when the television did not work in the first room. Whatever unit hangs on the wall was disgustingly dirty. Not sure what its purpose is.
Shelley
Shelley, 1-night trip
4/10 Fair
Staff was nice but the location and overall appeal of this lodging is questionable. Cheap overnight lodging for an individual but definitely not a place where I would feel safe bringing my family or a coworker. Does not have the amenities or appeal, can hear people in other rooms around you. Not even sure if there is WIFI but I did not get a password at check in and did not want to walk outside at night to go ask the staff for it. I think it is what it is, cheap lodging.
Brian
Brian, 1-night trip
6/10 Good
New rooms, staff courteous and helpful.
Abdullah
Abdullah, 1-night trip
6/10 Good
Mal olor, desorden y no colocan papel higienico
AUGUSTO
AUGUSTO, 2-night trip
6/10 Good
Buen personal pero muy malas condiciones del hotel, y falta de higiene
AUGUSTO
AUGUSTO, 1-night trip
8/10 Very good
Jeff
Jeff, 1-night trip
2/10 Poor
Nicholas
Nicholas, 1-night trip
10/10 Exceptional
Angel
Angel, 1-night trip
6/10 Good
Patisia
Patisia, 1-night trip
Keep exploring
- The Blake HotelStandard Link for The Blake Hotel
- Omni New Haven Hotel at YaleStandard Link for Omni New Haven Hotel at Yale
- New Haven Village SuitesStandard Link for New Haven Village Suites
- J House GreenwichStandard Link for J House Greenwich
- New Haven InnStandard Link for New Haven Inn
- Graduate by Hilton New HavenStandard Link for Graduate by Hilton New Haven
- Motel 6 Milford, CTStandard Link for Motel 6 Milford, CT
- New Haven HotelStandard Link for New Haven Hotel
- The Study at YaleStandard Link for The Study at Yale
- Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark by Wyndham Near Foxwoods CasinoStandard Link for Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark by Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino
- The Fox Tower at FoxwoodsStandard Link for The Fox Tower at Foxwoods
- Room-Fall Room 3min From Yale, And OtherStandard Link for Room-Fall Room 3min From Yale, And Other
- The Surfside HotelStandard Link for The Surfside Hotel
- Delamar WestportStandard Link for Delamar Westport
- The Cottage At Amos LakeStandard Link for The Cottage At Amos Lake
- The WatershedStandard Link for The Watershed
- Motel 6 New Haven - Branford, CTStandard Link for Motel 6 New Haven - Branford, CT
- Saybrook Point Resort & MarinaStandard Link for Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
- Water's Edge Resort & SpaStandard Link for Water's Edge Resort & Spa
- The Circle Hotel FairfieldStandard Link for The Circle Hotel Fairfield
- Inn at Harbor Hill MarinaStandard Link for Inn at Harbor Hill Marina
- Mohegan SunStandard Link for Mohegan Sun
- Hotel Hi-Ho - Contactless Check-InStandard Link for Hotel Hi-Ho - Contactless Check-In
- Mayflower Inn & Spa, Auberge CollectionStandard Link for Mayflower Inn & Spa, Auberge Collection
- Delamar West HartfordStandard Link for Delamar West Hartford