Online rezervasyon yapın veya bizi sabit hattan ücretsiz arayın:
00800 4488 21515 / +44 203 024 7876Pazartesi-Cuma 10.00-19.00. Bu saatler dışındaki aramalara İngilizce yanıt verilecektir.
"good location"Yorum, Hotels.com misafiri tarafından 10 Kas 2012 tarihinde yapılmıştır
it is enough good.
"Patpong plajında çok iyi bir konuma sahip."Yorum, Hotels.com misafiri tarafından 30 Tem 2012 tarihinde yapılmıştır
Kahvaltı dışında herşey iyiydi. Ama bir daha gitsem Kata Beach te almayı tercih ederim. Patpong sadece gece eğlencesi isteyenler için uygun. Kata ise cennet gibi bir doğaya sahip ve çok güzel restoranlar var.
Yorum, Hotels.com misafiri tarafından 26 Haz 2012 tarihinde yapılmıştır
Bu misafir bir yorum yazmadı.
Yorum, Hotels.com misafiri tarafından 30 Mar 2012 tarihinde yapılmıştır
Bu misafir bir yorum yazmadı.
"deniz sahili"Bu yorum 11 Şub 2012 tarihinde "izmir turkiye" şehrinden bilgin a. tarafından yapılmıştır
bu otel deniz kenarinda olmasina karsilik plaj umuma acik ve sezlonglar oradaki baskalari tarafindan 150 baht karsiligi kiralaniyor, bazi kisimlarda ise 400 baht oluyor. dip dibe konulan sezlonglarda rahat etmek pek mumkun degil, ayrica semsiyeler cok yipranmis ve tam koruma saglamiyor.yuzme havuzu ise gayet buyuk ve temiz, ikinci bir havuz daha var. tesis olarak guzel fakat kalabaligi sevmiyenlere uygun degil.otelden ayrilirken odayi kontrol etmek sebebiyle bekletilmek cok yanlis. hem hirsiz suphelisi durumuna konuyorsunuz hemde giriste garanti olarak aldiklari kredi karti bilgilerine ragmen sizi luzumsuz olarak bekletiyorlar. cok yakisiksiz bir durum
Ek yatak ücretlendirmesi otel politikasına tabidir.
Olası ekstra harcamalar için otele girişte, resmi kurumlarca düzenlenmiş fotoğraflı kimlik ve kredi kartı ya da nakit depozito gerekmektedir.
Özel talepler, otele giriş sırasında müsaitlik durumuna bağlıdır ve ek ödeme gerektirebilir. Özel talepler garanti edilemez.
Bu otelde engellilere yönelik özellikler bulunmamaktadır. Engellilere yönelik özelliklerin olduğu bir oda rezerve etmek istiyorsanız lütfen farklı bir otel seçin.
Massages are available on the beach and in the spa; other services include massages.
Misafirlere her sabah 7.00 ve 10.00 saatleri arasında ücretsiz büfe kahvaltı servisi yapılan bir restoran vardır.
Secret Cuisine - Bu aile restoranı, havuz manzaralıdır. Havanın müsait olması kaydıyla, misafirlere açık havada akşam yemeği servisi yapılır. Misafirler için akşam çayı servisi mevcuttur. Pazar, Pazartesi, Salı, Çarşamba ve Perşembe günlerinde kapalıdır.
Belirli saatlerde oda servisi mevcuttur.
Bu otel tarafından sunulan dinlenme olanakları arasında açık yüzme havuzu, sağlık kulübü buhar odası vardır.
Aşağıda listesi verilen dinlenme ve eğlenme etkinlikleri otelde veya otelin yakınındadır; bu etkinlikler ücretli olabilir.
Aksi belirtilmedikçe, aşağıdaki ücretler genel oda fiyatına dâhil değildir. Genel oda fiyatına dâhil olmamaları durumunda, bu ücretler otele giriş veya çıkış sırasında otel tarafından alınacaktır. Ücretler, örneğin konaklama süresinin uzunluğuna veya rezervasyon yaptırdığınız odaya bağlı olarak değişebilir. Bu otel sizden şu ücretleri alacağını bize bildirdi:
Otelin bize bildirdiği tüm ücretleri dâhil ettik. Bununla birlikte, örneğin, konaklama süresine veya rezervasyon yaptığınız odaya bağlı olarak ücretler değişebilir.
Servis, giriş veya çıkış sırasında otel tarafından aşağıdaki ücretler ve depozitolar alınır.
Yukarıdaki liste tüm bilgileri içermeyebilir. Ücretlere ve depozitolara vergi dâhil olmayabilir, ayrıca ücretler ve depozitolar değişebilir.
Ek yatak ücretlendirmesi otel politikasına tabidir.
Olası ekstra harcamalar için otele girişte, resmi kurumlarca düzenlenmiş fotoğraflı kimlik ve kredi kartı ya da nakit depozito gerekmektedir.
Özel talepler, otele giriş sırasında müsaitlik durumuna bağlıdır ve ek ödeme gerektirebilir. Özel talepler garanti edilemez.
"Not a good choice for overnight stay near airport"
I booked the hotel because it was close to the airport as I got to Phuket after midnight. However, the facility was too bad for the price. Our room was on the second floor, which was partly unfurnished. The room was big, with a lot of open space. Breakfast was bad as well. At the end of the trip, I found out there is no need to book a hotel near airport. […] I should have just stayed at the beach resort directly. DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
We arrived late at night and found I was upgraded to a villa. The room was nice, but the floor was extremly strained (possibly dirty). The next morning I was able to see the hotel in the light. It had a beautiful pool, and a wonderful breakfast buffet. I would stay here again It was close to the airport which was convenient for me.Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Thoroughly enjoyed it!"
Great place! We stayed there for 5 nights. Loved the pool villa - very comfortable and relaxing. Very quiet place. Nice breakfast buffet. The only cons are minor: not many TV channels, no reasonably-priced market nearby.Gerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Need renovation"
Rooms is nice but the Deluxe room block need to be refurbishedGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Great hotel"
A little hard to find but a great hotel. We were upgraded to a better room on check-in and were very pleased with our room. The breakfast at the hotel was good but we went to the beach for all other meals. There are great restaurants and a small shopping area on the beach. Very quiet location with jungle around the hotel.Gerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Very relaxing"
Place was very nice. Staff's english was hard to understand at times. Played the same music over and over, which sometimes got really annoying. Really easy to get to the beach and to a (very small) town with nice beach-side restaurants and touristy shops. Absolutely need to use their car service to get anywhere else besides the small town though.Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Outstanding resort... in the middle of nowhere"
The L'Esprit de Naiyang is a wonderful smaller resort, don't get me wrong. If you're looking for an isolated and quiet villa or room just off the beach with not much else to bother you, this place is paradise. I would recommend this place for couples who just want to get away from it all and get some romancing going. Now, unfortunately, if you're looking […] to explore Phuket or eat anywhere other than the resort's own restaurant, you have to pay huge taxi fees or prepare yourself for a long trek because you're in the middle of nowhere. Bottom line, the resort is beautiful and the staff are very friendly and highly attentive, but if you're looking to really see the sights prepare to shell out the cash. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Last night at Phuket"
Booked hotel as last night of vacation to be closer to the airport. Trying to find the hotel proved a challenge for the taxi driver as the street address wasnt known to him and the signage from the main road was very poor. On arrival at the hotel there was no one to meet and greet us and we had to find staff to assist. The staff were very helpful once […] we checked in and we received an upgrade to a bure type room back from the main pool. The rooms are new and very well appointed with very good use of indoor and outdoor space. Air condition units in the bedroom and lounge. The toilet, bath facilities are adjacent to the main bedroom but are not fully enclosed. To get to the main town you have to cross the small stream using a small barge which is manned by hotel staff and walk about 100 metres to the small fishing village. The village has a very low key relaxed feel to it where you could really relax by the beach and let the cares of the world pass you by. We had a meal at a cafe and enjoyed a fish thai meal with the fish fresh caught earlier in the day. Used the hotel pool which is quite unique with the rooms situated next to the pool. At night the only draw back is the mosquitoes that you have to the fend off. The hotel staff gave us no warning about the mosquitoes or insect repellant so in the morning I had a few welts on my arms. During the dry season it may be different but during the wet season be prepared to fight the mosquitoes. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Not 5 Star"
Booked online when arrived midnight no room service, no bar not able to get food or drink on arrival plus no hot water in shower when using that! Breakfast was below par actually, bit disappointing. Pluses, close to airport, nice rooms, good service. Would not book again though.Gerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Couples"
Excellent hotel, very relaxing , super friendly staff! Great breakfast!! The beach is very close and very nice and peaceful :) Highlly recommend for couples!!Gerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Looking forward to our next stay"
My mom and I stayed in a garden cottage. When we arrived it was raining and the staff kindly helped us get through the downpour. We loved the cottage, the proximity to the beach, the pontoon boat across the river and the exquisite peaceful setting. The design is really beautiful. Taking everything into consideration, the resort has the potential for […] being 5 star, a bit rugged and luxurious at the same time. What is lacking is more organization: there need to be more hooks to hang up towels, robes and wet items, more towels available in the rooms, amenities need to be checked: we had 2 ceramic shampoo containers at the tub, conditioner was missing. There was also a wet (from the rain) towel serving as a curtain in the bathroom. These are details that need attention. The lobby was beautiful except for the clutter of extra beds which could easily be hid with a room screen. Lastly, the breakfast is only mediocre. Appears to be a shortage of staff. We arrived at 9:30 am and the fresh fruit was all gone. Would have been nice to have congee, a traditional Thai breakfast. Dinner was also mediocre although the wait staff was very good. Fortunately, we found good dining on the beach outside the resort. We made good use of the DVD collection and reading material and appreciate the availability, especially for a rainy night. We are planning to return and hope in time the glitches are worked out. I would definitely recommend the resort to friends. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Good hotel"
A great hotel in a convenient location close to airport for a short stay. We went for walk on beach then ate in hotel and had good meal not a huge selection but common thai food that was good. Would not stay here for extended period but for up to 4 days it is perfect. Next to quiet park close to small village. Read some bad previous reviews but found […] these in our case to be wrong. The small ferry was a bit weird but no probems. The staff were excellent and we had a room next to pool that was very good. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Not worth the money"
The hotel is not a resort - it is outside and away from everything. When you go to town or beach, a river crossed by a small pull ferry. It is only staffed between the hours. 7 to 20 then you have to even find their way home. Taxi drivers are overpriced for the trip and it is not okay for a 4 star hotel to offer its customers this. The hotel is also […] not built quite finished yet. DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"4 star hotel - but only 2 star quality"
Unfortunately a hotel with a staff with VERY POOR service. The hotel is separated from Nai Yang Beach with a small river, during the day the hotel has a raft that carries guests to the beach, but this service is only available to 8 pm. This means that you should take a taxi for miles instead of going a few hundred meters. Breakfast was very poor quality. The […] pool has only a few sun beds, and they are placed in the water?!?! It could be a nice hotel, but we had a very bad experience, and will not recommend the hotel! DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Relaxed"
They need to improve on keeping the pool clean and the other water around the complex clean as it was a real turn off. We asked for a late check out and was told no, but no one checked into our room as we waited until 5 pm to leave the hotel. The staff and food was very good but only other complaint was that they had the same CD playing for the whole […] week which needless to say was very tiring. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"American couple at L'esprit de Nai Yang"
I wrote a much longer review on Tripadvisor.com and I would highly recommend checking out some of the other reviews that travelers have posted there. Keep in mind, the few poor reviews that this hotel has gotten came in the first months of its operation. As of my writing, they have only been open for 6 months but have already made tremendous improvements. In […] short, my fiance and I loved this hotel and would happily recommend it to anyone. It is a great place to stay if you are looking for a peaceful vacation for a good price. The crazier parts of Phuket are about an hour away but you are still within walking distance of plenty of good restaurants, massage parlors, shops, convenience stores, bars, etc. The beach is beautiful, relatively empty and , most importantly, very close. The hotel staff is awesome, the services is awesome, the food and drinks are awesome and cheap. It is a great deal for the price and was the best vacation I have ever taken (I have only been on a few). DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Very good, but the barge is a challenge"
everything was great about this place, but you have to cross a little river to get to and from the hotel. the barge stops at 8pm, so if you are coming back late you need a taxiGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"just a 3* place to stay, no beach"
We stayed there for two days as a couple (after spending 5 days at Holiday Inn Resort). Our first impression was rather negative: noice AC in the room, inability to provide us with a Q or K- bed as requested per booking and, more importantly, no beach. Yes, despite what Hotel says - they do not have beach. However, there is a public beach stripe somewhat […] 1000 f from the hotel which you may use. Of course it is not clean etc. But.... And wait, there is a good " but". The staff is friendly. The hotel has a good swiming pool. A supernice ferry-guy can cross you from the canal to the other side of the area and you may walk to some other beach areas and stay there for the whole day long for a small fee. Room cleaners are great and receptionists are supergood and helpful. They can arrange a nice massage for a nice price to your room. The food, however, is overpriced and in general we did not like it. So we always had our lunch and dinner at the near by places. So major remark: this is a 3* hotel (rather than a resort) with a great idea but poor materialisation of this idea. I have a feeling that they started with ambitious plan and ran out of money:) But I would recommend this place for those who need to spend 1-2 days out of the common popular places. DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Not impressed"
Writing a bad review about this hotel and complaining would not do it justice. Take my word on it, its lousy The main fault is with the staff. They are kids trying to run a hotel with countless problems Stay at the Indigo Peal up the road.Gerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"we had a wonderful time, will definitely be back next trip."
being only 5 months old, it's seems so fresh & clean. the room is tastefully done and cannot complain about the staff and wonderful service. the breakfast can include a few more items.Gerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"L'esprit de Naiyang"
Its a very new hotel so occupancy is low even on weekends. Naiyang is pretty far from the hustle and bustle of Phuket centre so if you're looking for a quiet, peaceful time this is certainly the place to go to. The staff were very attentive and the place was generally clean.Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Not a bad choice"
We spent 5 nights here in late September in a Garden Villa room. The rooms are quite spacious and staff were friendly and helpful. The hotel is only a 5 min walk from Naiyang village, although you do have to cross a small stream, but there are paddle boats and a pontoon to do that and it is no problem. Certainly for the rate we paid (special introductory […] rate) it was well worth it and a good choice. There are great restaurants and bars in Naiyang and I would recommend the very first seafood restaurant that you encounter on the left as you get to the village (can't remember the name). It has individual little huts as tables and is excellent. The hotel is only 10 mins from the airport and a cab from the airport is less than 200 baht. Only negative was the hotel would not allow outside cabs to come and pick us up to go back to the airport and insisted we use one of their cars as a cost of 400 baht. They do not offer an airport pick up or drop off service. DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"BEST HOTEL IN PHUKET!"
I would definitely stay here again. We had such a great experience-- they picked us up at the airport, showed us exactly how to get to the town (restaurants, beach), arranged a driver to take us to and from the ferry to go to Kho Phi Phi, and opened the kitchen early so we could eat breakfast before our flight left. The hotel itself is also beautiful, […] especially the pool. The rooms are clean and brand new. All in all, it's a great place to stay in Phuket- it's very reasonably priced, close to the airport, and staffed by the sweetest people. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
Bu misafir bir yorum yazmadı.Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Parfait"
Hotel trés sympa. Chambre spacieuse et propre. Piscine immense.Trés bel hotel. Je le recommande.Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Super Hotel"
Das Hotel ist ruhig und nicht direkt am Strand gelegen. Zum Strand braucht man zu Fuß ca. 3 Minuten, wobei ein hoteleigenens kostenloses Shuttle- Ruderboot benutzt werden muss (von morgens bis 22 Uhr in Betrieb). Zum nächsten Örtchen (Naiyang) dauert es zu Fuß etwa 7 Minuten und dort gibt es jede Menge Restaurants. Wir haben in einer Green Villa gewohnt […] und waren mit der Villa sehr zufrieden. Es gibt viel Platz und alles ist schön eingerichtet. Vom Schlafzimmer kommt man zum Badezimmer im Freien, leider gibt es an dieser Stelle keinen Verdunkelungsvorhang im Zimmer. Der Pool ist der Wahnsinn! Das gesamte Personal war sehr freundlich und zuvorkommend. Ich bin ein sehr empfindlicher Schläfer und schon geringer Lärm weckt mich nachts auf. Leider habe ich trotz Ohropax die Klimaanlage des Zimmers gehört, vor allem das Klicken beim automatischen Ein- und Ausschalten. Wir haben die Klimaanlage komplett abgestellt, um gut schlafen zu können. Aber wie gesagt, ich bin ein sehr empfindlicher Schläfer. Das Frühstück war gut. Es gibt nach Wunsch frisch zubereitet Omelettes, westliche und asiatische Gerichte. Vom Flughafen in Phuket sind es nur wenige Km zum L'Esprit de Naiyang. Mehr als 150-200 Baht sollte eine Taxifahrt keinesfalls kosten. Ein 7-Eleven gibt es am Naiyang Beach nicht, nur auf dem Weg vom Flughafen zum Hotel. Wer also nicht die überteuerten Beach- Preise zahlen möchte, kann auf der Taxifahrt einen kurzen Stop beim 7-Eleven machen und günstig Snacks und Getränke einkaufen. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"家族連れやのんびりしたい人向け"
カップルで利用しましたが、他の多くの人が家族利用でした。 写真にあるプールサイドの部屋と、受付、朝食を食べる建物の部屋(3階建て)があり、どちらかの部屋になるようです。予約の際に確認した方が良いでしょう。 私達はプールサイドではなく3階ったのですが、その分景色が良いし、カーテンをあけていても見られる心配がなく快適でした。エレベーターなどは無いのですが、荷物はスタッフがあげてくれるので問題はありません。 ナイヤンビーチへも近く、人も多くはなく、少なくもなく、すごく快適でした。一方でパトンなどの繁華街へはタクシーで1時間弱(ホテルに頼むと往復1600バーツ、運転手は行った先でまたピックアップしてくれる)かかるので、のんびりしたいがメインの人におすすめです。ホテルからはかなり近く15分程度(300 […] 〜400バーツ)です。このホテル、ナイヤンビーチそれぞれ日本人には全然会いませんでした。 DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"angenehmes preiswürdiges hotel"
kein superhotel,aber gut gelegen und vernünftige PreiseGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
Valittiin tämä hotelli, koska lentokenttä on lähellä ja oli aikainen lento. Henkilökunta siivoojia lukuunottamatta tylyjä, ei ollenkaan Thaimaalaista Ystävällisyyttä. Aamupala vaatimaton, munakkaan paistaja plussaa. Hotellilta kulkeminen hankalaa, eivät katsoneet hyvällä, kun käytti paikallis- Taksia, kuski jättikin portin ulkopuolelle. Aurinkotuoleja […] altaalla hyvin vähän. Joinakin päivinä altaalla henkilökunta soitti musiikkia todella isolla, jos halusi lukea tai vaikka nukkua ei onnistunut kovan metelin takia. Ranta lähellä ja todella hyvä, missä myös ravintoloita ja kauppoja. Kulkeminen pienen joen yli lautalla rannalle, lautta toimi hyvin aamu 7 ja ilta 10 välillä. Kaikenkaikkiaan tuli tunne kuin hotellia ei johtaisi kukaan... Emme valitse tätä Hotellia uudelleen. DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Plesant stay, very helpful staff!"
Very beautiful clean new hotel. The staff was very helpful. The room was very comfortable. It's very quiet at night. The breakfast was good. We just spent 1 night there to then head to phiphi island this is why we chose a hotel near the airport. The surrounding is very green but I don't think there's much to do outside the hotel and it's quite far from […] the busting patong beach area. The staff will happily help you to find taxis to drive you downtown. The swimming pool is really nice. The beach is clean but quite deserted and not as nice as on phiphi island. We just spent one night and loved it but our aim wasn't to spend time in Phuket. As we landed at night, the taxis didn't want to use their meters. Though it's a very short drive from the airport, we had to bargain a lot and had to pay 300 baht. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
DEJLIGT lækkert hotel , meget afslappende ophold , meget hjælpson personale .Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Pessimo"
Camere puzzolenti, manutenzione assente, situato in mezzo al nullaGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"Endroit tranquille à 5minutes de la plage"
Excellent service. Cachet intéressant: la traversée de la petite rivière pour aller à la plage. Seul inconvénient, il faut revenir avant 20:00 hre car le bac ne fonctionne plus.Gerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Avskilt hotell"
+Mycke fin hotellanläggning och trevligt och tillmötesgående hotellpersonal. +Avskilt och tyst omgivning nattetid -AC-anläggningen på balkongen förde väsen när den slog av o på nattetid -Ingen infopärm i vare sig rummet el. i recepionen som gav någon info om hotellet och dess omgivning -Glasväggar mellan sovrum o toa/dusch. Kan väl upplevas som lite […] fräckt, men för oss som var 2 vuxna+ 1 tonårsdotter så var det inte optimalt. DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Alles prima mit "Aber ...""
Konzeptionell prima designed, in Detail und Ausführung nie komplettiert. Beispiel: die Pool-Bar braucht noch max. 2 Stunden Arbeit, um die Sicht auf den am Boden herumliegenden Kram mit einer Verblendung zu verdecken, aber niemand merkt's. D.h. weder werden die 2 Stunden Aufwand geleistet, noch wird das Zeugs je hinter irgend einer Abdeckung verschwinden. Wenn's […] keinen stört, ist alles okay. Personal ganz prima, sehr schwach mit Englisch, Manager sehr hilfsbereit, topfit in Englisch. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"L Esprit de Naiyang"
Nybyggt hotel som ligger nära Nay Yang beach Rummen är fina med 2 avdelningar men toalett och badrum ligger utanför rummet men i anslutning till rummet så att en del små djur passerar rakt igenom toalettdelen. Frukosten höll tyvärr inte måttet på detta hotelletGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
"Meget bra anlegg"
Hadde 14 fine dager her. Hotellet har god standard, hyggelig betjening, god service og meget bra renhold. En elv måtte krysses for å komme til "byen" og stranden. Hotellet hadde en tautrukket "ferje" til å transportere gjestene over elven. Denne var annonsert tilgjengelig fra 7 am til 8 pm, men var under hele vårt opphold åpen til 11 pm. Ta med lommelykt […] da det er ganske mørkt gjennom skogen mellom hotellet og "byen" Etter 11 pm. Må en bruke taxi til og fra hotellet, 300 bath. DevamıGerçek Expedia misafiri yorumu
"4 star hotel - but only 2 star quality"
Unfortunately a hotel with a staff with VERY POOR service. The hotel is separated from Nai Yang Beach with a small river, during the day the hotel has a raft that carries guests to the beach, but this service is only available to 8 pm. This means that you should take a taxi for miles instead of going a few hundred meters. Breakfast was very poor quality. The […] pool has only a few sun beds, and they are placed in the water?!?! It could be a nice hotel, but we had a very bad experience, and will not recommend the hotel! DevamıGerçek Hotels.com misafiri yorumu
Bu sitede bulunan yorumlar ve derecelendirmeler müşterilerin ve tedarikçilerin kişisel görüşleridir, Hotels.com’un görüşlerini temsil etmez ve onları yansıtmaz. Yapılan yorumlar yüzünden oluşabilecek herhangi bir zarardan ne Hotels.com ne de bu yorum içeriğini sağlayan taraflar sorumlu tutulabilir